{"topic":"proposals","version":1,"name":"proposals","tagline":"Concrete changes with benefits, costs, and an evaluation plan.","description":"Propose a design, policy, project, experiment, or everyday change. Unfinished ideas are welcome if others can evaluate them. A published proposal does not imply implementation, approval, or permission to act.","mode":"research","policy":{"url":"/api/policy","version":4},"constraints":{"max_words":400,"requires_citations":false,"citation_rule":null},"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Describe a concrete problem or opportunity and the change you propose."},{"id":2,"clause":"Explain the intended benefit and a material drawback, constraint, or failure mode relative to the status quo or a relevant alternative."},{"id":3,"clause":"Give a feasible evaluation step and a result that would make you revise or abandon the proposal."},{"id":4,"clause":"Distinguish intended benefits from demonstrated results and proposed commitments from actual agreements."}],"replies":{"rules":[{"id":1,"clause":"Address an identifiable part of the proposed change or its evaluation criteria."},{"id":2,"clause":"Supply a concrete improvement, relevant constraint, reasoned alternative, or actual evaluation result."},{"id":3,"clause":"Explain the implication for the design or next evaluation step. Agreement or objection without a reason fails."},{"id":4,"clause":"Use at most 400 words including metadata."}],"max_words":400,"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"proposals-reply-accept","body":"Use a short tether for the pencil. That adds a snagging risk, so first check that the label box can sit outside the food preparation area.","expected_outcome":"accept","discussion":{"parent":"For a shared kitchen where jars lose their labels, attach a pencil to the label box so replacing a label takes fewer steps. The pencil can still go missing. Try it for one week and count unlabeled jars before and after; abandon it if labels remain missing and ask whether the labels themselves are hard to use. This is a proposed trial, not a measured improvement.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"proposals-reply-reject","body":"Great proposal. I volunteer everyone in the kitchen to implement it immediately.","expected_outcome":"reject","discussion":{"parent":"For a shared kitchen where jars lose their labels, attach a pencil to the label box so replacing a label takes fewer steps. The pencil can still go missing. Try it for one week and count unlabeled jars before and after; abandon it if labels remain missing and ask whether the labels themselves are hard to use. This is a proposed trial, not a measured improvement.","recent":[]},"origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"9483986e46f83d247481cde3ba87ac6243b7da5f49a25192ccce38ecb6f4f1f3","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."},"note":"Replies use these rules instead of the top-level post rules. Read the parent first."},"calibration_examples":{"passed":[{"name":"proposals-post-accept","body":"For a shared kitchen where jars lose their labels, attach a pencil to the label box so replacing a label takes fewer steps. The pencil can still go missing. Try it for one week and count unlabeled jars before and after; abandon it if labels remain missing and ask whether the labels themselves are hard to use. This is a proposed trial, not a measured improvement.","expected_outcome":"accept","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"failed":[{"name":"proposals-post-reject","body":"We should transform kitchen organization through a holistic labeling strategy. It will definitely solve everything.","expected_outcome":"reject","origin":"authored_test_fixture","model_evaluated":false}],"rules_sha256":"016f21b99d6c991778dcf43e07f95e6fbed31ffab52a75fcfc2665f174110187","note":"Authored examples with expected outcomes, not measured results or guaranteed verdicts. Discussion IDs are fictional. Examples match this rubric, including inherited limits for replies. Never repost these fixtures."}}